The Skinny on Holiday Weight Gain

Tipping the scales this holiday season?

Reports of your holiday weight gain have been greatly exaggerated. Media stories often suggest that the average person gains 7 to 10 pounds between Thanksgiving and Christmas. And in surveys, people say they gain, on average, about five pounds this time of year.

But several studies now show that the average weight gain during the winter holidays is just one pound.

The news isn’t all good. Most people don’t ever lose the pound of weight they put on during the holidays, according to a report in The New England Journal of Medicine. Since the average weight gain during adulthood is about one to two pounds a year, that means much of midlife weight gain can be explained by holiday eating.

For people who are already overweight, the holiday weight news is worse. Although the average gain is only one pound, people who are already overweight tend to gain a lot more. One study found that overweight people gained five pounds or more during the holidays.

And we start packing on that extra pound of holiday weight early in life. Researchers at the University of Oklahoma studied holiday weight gain among college students during the Thanksgiving break. The students were weighed the day before Thanksgiving, then weighed again about two weeks later. The average weight gain for the 94 students was about one pound. Students who were of normal weight gained about a half a pound during the period. Students who were overweight, meaning their body mass index was 25 or more, gained about two pounds.

Holly Hull, the lead researcher on the Oklahoma study, says Thanksgiving marks the beginning of a “high risk” time for the overweight. “I think the number of people who only overeat at the Thanksgiving meal is slim to none,” said Dr. Hull. “The holiday season doesn’t represent one day of overeating. You have this period that extends through the new year where there’s more alcohol, more snacks, more finger foods and appetizers that are energy dense.”

Comments are no longer being accepted.

Eating is an enjoyment in life. It’s a punishment if one is allowed to look only and not to eat delicious, tasty food. It’s a normal phenomenon that living things store up energy to prepare for the long, cold winter. Human beings are no exception. Overeating requires self-control, self-discipline. One day of overeating can be easily solved by eating less on the same day or other days plus more physical exercise, but overeating over a period is comparatively harder to solve. One may need the whole winter and even the following spring to tackle and remove the overweight, be it one pound or five pounds. It’s different from the saying “No pain, no gain”, it’s “No gain, no pain.” Stop being a couch potato.

Studying college students weight gain is an odd choice – a) many students eat garbage all the time. When I was in college, I gained the weight at school, not home for the holidays and b) the young don’t put on weight like middle aged and older people. I have stopped baking for people during the holidays. I don’t like to keep too much junk around, and hate to be given or offered cookies at every turn. What about a nice bottle of Olive oil or something like that when going holiday visiting?

Although not eating more than one typically would during this time of the year is a bit more of a challenge, particularly at the office where snacks, candies and extras are often made available by your “loving” co-workers, it’s not impossible.

My in-laws make it fun by hosting a contest every year to see who can lose the most weight from Thanksgiving day to New Years day. The entire familiy goes out to dinner after the contest and the winner eats for free. Not eating is punishment but eating in moderation as well as eating with a goal in mind is smart and can be fun (like with my wife’s family) during the holidays.

Most of the stuff that’s around at the office is just GARBAGE- doesn’t that make it easy to resist? I mean, it’s the cheap stuff that no one wants, often “food” that has been given to someone who has no desire to eat it so they bring it into work. Why not pass up on the pure junk and “save up” for some good homemade pie or a home-cooked festive meal?

Studying differential weight gain among ‘normal’ and ‘obese’ college students right after Thanksgiving is interesting, but a more useful study would be to compare weight gain right after Thanksgiving with weight gain at the same period in the spring semester. For college students Thanksgiving marks the start of the period in which papers and projects are due, final exams loom on the horizon, etc. In other words, this is a high stress period (and usually lower activity because of weather); how does it compare to spring semester’s high stress period? do heavier college students gain more weight during both stressful periods, or only in the fall?

As take me for example,I almost exercise every day so I am not afraid of eating too much food.Delicious food is a precious present that God give us anyone can’t easily resist it. But how to avoiding weight gain is an important lesson you must learn.Because wheh you enjoy it you must pay the price late.

I usually have this attitude of “Oh, well, there is no such thing as dieting during the holidays for me. If I’m taking a few weeks off of my life, so be it (because there is no guarantee we will reach old age anyway), and at least I’ll be happy enjoying the food along the way.”

Yeah, well, that was before I went away for Thanksgiving vacation and came back five pounds heavier. OMG, and I haven’t even made it to Christmas. It is definitely not easy to stay slim during the holidays. And I regularly work out with a personal trainer, and that still didn’t stop the pounds from attaching themselves. Yikes.

I never had this problem until I hit my mid-30’s. No wonder most Americans of this age or older are so fat.

There is more to life than eating. All you need is a little self control. The holidays should mean more to us than good food and presents anyways. I mean, do most of us know that Christmas is when Jesus was born? Sometimes it’s hard to tell.

You have to exercise you cant sit on the couch and eat junk food all day its not healthy because if you keep it up you will maybe get o fat that your children wont like you.You’ll have to sit in a wheel chair and you wont be happy

Dakota, Jesus was not born on Christmas Day, he was born some time in July. Christmas is just the day to remember his birth and love and bring light into the “dark days of winter”. Christmas now has become so commercialized, sometimes i wish there wasn’t so many GOOD foods to chose from, then we all wouldn’t have to worry about anything and would’t have anything to resist:)
cave man diet! woo

Sheila | Live Well 360° December 18, 2008 · 9:55 pm

I know this article is over a year old, but I had to comment.

These “reports” crack me up. 7-10 pounds of ACTUAL FAT. Do you know how much a person would have to eat in order to gain that much actual fat!?!?! Its water!! Ha.

I actually just posted a podcast about “holiday food stressin” and overeating during the holidays. Check it out if you are interested: //livewell360.com/2008/12/podcast-holiday-food-stressin/

Sheila

the key to avoiding holiday weight gain is simply BALANCE. Yes, its true that you will be in more situations where you’re offered delicious and fattening foods because, lets face it, thats just part of the holidays. It’s ok to indulge once in a while at a party… just dont go overboard. And when you’re back at home, avoid surrounding yourself with MORE junk food. Make your home a place for healthy eating. Keep fresh fruits and vegetables around for snacks instead of chips and cookies; and drink milk and water instead of soda and sugary juices. dont stress about it. remember, its just food!

is your life really going to be THAT drastic if you have an extra cookie? Or if you don’t get a taste of the eggnog? Probably not.

I blog about my weight and my battles with weight gain over the holiday season. Blogging helps keep me honest. It does not prevent me from eating too much over the holiday season, but it does help. My blog is //www.fitchick365.com

I have also started a blog for the same reason as -fitchick365, it keeps me honest, and holds ME responsible for my eating habits. I have battles weight gain, and weight loss for years now and find the holiday seasons the worst when it comes to weight fluctuations. My blog is //www.meetmylovehandles.com

I think studying college students is odd here. What is usually about 2 weeks after Thanksgiving? Exams. Exams mean stress and for many students, that means poor eating habits (overeating, not eating, eating at odd hours, eating junk food, etc.). I know my eating habits weren’t the greatest around exam time because I was too busy studying to eat and when I did eat, it was probably far more than I should have at one time. (I graduated from college in May 2010.)

The holidays are probably the worst time to watch your weight. Yet studies such as these which links holiday weight gain to adult weight gain are certainly enough to motivate anyone not to get a second slice of pumpkin pie. :-)

In my blog, I gathered a list of tips about how you can watch what you eat this Christmas and NOT feel like you are depriving yourself. Is it possible to avoid holiday weight gain and still eat what you want? I think it is.

You can check out my post at:

//cheersladies.com/2010/12/4-tips-to-avoid-holiday-weight-gain-and-still-eat-anything-you-want/